Homemade Sauerkraut is rich in probiotics and vitamins, and made with two simple ingredients – cabbage and salt. It is slightly acidic and sour, and full of flavor. One taste and you will never go back to the commercial sauerkraut sold in supermarkets. Sauerkraut is incredibly versatile, and goes with so many things. Try it hot on a reuben, cold on a salad, dressed up with sautéed onions and bacon, or on its own as a refreshing snack. Did I mention that it’s super simple to make?
Several years ago on a visit to a friend in Germany, the subject of sauerkraut came up. I asked “how is it made?” The reply was cabbage and salt. I couldn’t believe that only those two ingredients produced sauerkraut, so I asked again.
The friend was slightly perturbed that I asked again. He again answered, cabbage and salt! Armed with that knowledge, the Master Taste Tester suggested that we should try our hand at making sauerkraut, which we did. I first blogged about it in 2012!
Fast forward to now with six years of continued experimentation. So far, we have consumed gallons of the sauerkraut, with more jars fermenting away! Unlike the original experiment, we’ve learned a few things along the way, and have produced a consistently better product. In fact, in the words of the Master Taste Tester, “this is fantastic!” Up to this point, his supreme compliment was “this is pretty good!”
With all of this experimentation, I thought that it was time to revisit the making of sauerkraut.
Ingredients for Homemade Sauerkraut:
As I previously indicated, the ingredients for homemade sauerkraut are simple – cabbage and salt. As far as the cabbage is concerned, I’ve tried organic, regular, supermarket, and farmer’s market cabbage. It seems from all of this that the best cabbage to use is that which is freshest. Otherwise, we can’t really be definitive about the best in terms of source.
For the salt, I consistently use coarse light grey Celtic sea salt. You can use other salts. However, you should never use salt with additives like iodide, sugar, or anti-caking agents such as calcium silicate. The reason is that they can interfere with the fermentation process. Therefore, you should stay away from table salt, iodized salt, and Kosher salt. The best salts to use are those that are unprocessed, i.e., salts that still have their complete natural profile of minerals.
Shredding the Cabbage for the Homemade Sauerkraut:
The first thing that I did was to shred the cabbage. In the past, I’ve used a food processor or a sharp knife. The key is shredding the cabbage very thinly. My old food processor didn’t do a good job at all with shredding, so I used a sharp knife. My new food processor has a variable size shredding blade, which is perfect. I’ve found that the perfect size, at least for us is 2-mm shreds.
Before I shred the cabbage, I cut away the core and try to cut away as many of the stalky bits as possible.
Massaging and Pounding the Cabbage for the Homemade Sauerkraut:
Through the years, I’ve found that 32 ounces of shredded cabbage is the perfect quantity for the half-gallon mason jars that I use. So as not to get overloaded with the shredding of the cabbage, I initially work in two stages of 16-ounces each of cabbage. For the first 16-ounces of cabbage, I sprinkle on one teaspoon of the sea salt. Interestingly, all of the recipes that I’ve looked at call for 1 tablespoon of salt per pound. I personally think that this is too much salt. The 1 teaspoon per pound works perfectly, at least for us.
I massage the salt into the cabbage with my hands. Then, I repeat the process with the additional 16-ounces of shredded cabbage and 1 teaspoon of sea salt.
Now comes the time-consuming part of making the Sauerkraut – massaging the salt and cabbage together to begin breaking down the cabbage so that it releases some of its liquid. I combine all of the cabbage in a large bowl, and use my very clean hands to do this. After about 5 minutes, the cabbage begins to release some liquid and to wilt. It also looses quite a bit of volume.
At this point, I let the cabbage sit for about 30 minutes. Then, I use a potato masher to pound the cabbage for another 10 minutes. During this time, I lift up the cabbage with the potato masher several times and pound it down again.
Packing the Cabbage into Mason Jars for the Homemade Sauerkraut:
Through the years, I’ve consistently used half-gallon mason jars for the fermentation of the cabbage. I start by placing a canning funnel on top of the jar. Then, I use kitchen tongs to add the cabbage to the jar. I use a tart tamper to push the cabbage down in the jar. Then, I add a cabbage leaf on top of the cabbage, and a glass weight.
I’ve found that the age of the cabbage has somewhat of an impact on the amount of liquid released during the massaging and pounding. Basically, the fresher the cabbage, the more liquid is released. Generally, however, I need to add up to 2-cups of filtered water mixed with 3/4 teaspoon of sea salt to ensure that the cabbage is fully submerged in the jar.
As a final step I put the lid on the jar with an air-lock device. The air-lock device seals air out of the fermenting jar, but allows air and carbon dioxide from the fermenting sauerkraut to safely escape. Thus, it helps to form an anaerobic environment (as further discussed below).
Now comes the fermentation wait! In the fermenting stage, a biochemical change is brought about by the anaerobic or partially anaerobic oxidation of carbohydrates by either micro-organisms or enzymes. In sauerkraut, the fermentation process has a very specific purpose – to quickly proliferate through the food by Lactobacilli, lactic acid-producing bacteria. This causes the pH to be reduced, making the environment acidic and therefore unsuitable for the growth of unwanted bacteria.
In order for the sauerkraut to be a success, it must go through three different fermentation stages.
First, the fermentation is initiated by Leuconostoc mesenteroides, which produce carbon dioxide. This effectively replaces the oxygen in the jar, making the environment anaerobic or oxygen-free. When the lactic acids reach between .25 and .30%, Leuconostoc mesenteriodes bacteria slow down and die off. This takes between one and three days, depending on the temperature.
Second, Lactobacillus plantarum and Lactobacillus cumeris continue to ferment until a lactic acid level of 1.5 to 2% is reached. High salt and low temperature inhibit these bacteria, so the cabbage should not be over salted. In addition, the sauerkraut should not yet be refrigerated. Stage two continues for 10 to 30 days, depending on the temperature.
Finally Lactobacillus brevis completes the fermentation process. When the lactic acid reaches 2 to 2.5%, the Lactobacillus brevis reaches its maximum growth and the fermentation is complete. This final stage lasts for less than a week.
So what does this mean? First, the brine must always be above the level of the cabbage. Second, too much salt is bad. Third, an oxygen-free environment is essential to ensure that the good bacteria grow and the bad bacteria die. Finally, the whole fermentation process takes time.
The most interesting part of watching the fermentation occurs during the first week of the process. During this time, the color of the cabbage changes from green to a light beige.
After the bubbling stops and the liquid level drops, another two to three weeks is required for the completion of the fermentation process.
Is the wait worth it? Absolutely! The Reubens made with the homemade sauerkraut are incredible. In addition, the Master Taste Tester eats the sauerkraut like he would a salad. Yum!
- 4 pounds of Cabbage (2 heads) or enough to make 32 ounces shredded
- 2 3/4 teaspoons light grey Celtic sea salt or other unprocessed sea salt, divided (See Note 1)
- 1 1/2 to 2 cups filtered water (See Note 2)
- Remove outer leaves from cabbage, retaining 1 leaf.
- Quarter cabbage and remove core. Cut into fine shreds with a sharp knife or food processor (See Note 3). Add salt at a rate of 1 teaspoon per pound of shredded cabbage. Massage cabbage with hands for 5 minutes to begin the process of breaking down the cabbage and the release of brine. Let sit for 30 minutes. Using potato masher, pound cabbage for 10 minutes.
- Combine 2 cups of filtered water with remaining 3/4 teaspoon of sea salt.
- Add cabbage to sterilized half-gallon mason jar (See Note 4). Top cabbage with retained cabbage leaf and weight (See Note 5). Add enough filtered water mixed with sea salt to ensure that the liquid level is above the cabbage.
- Place lid with air-lock device on jar. Sauerkraut takes between 3 and 4 weeks to properly ferment. Yield: 2 pounds.
Chula's Expert Tips
- Note 1: Never use salt with additives like iodide, sugar, or anti-caking agents such as calcium silicate. The reason is that they can interfere with the fermentation process. Therefore, stay away from table salt, iodized salt, and Kosher salt. The best salts to use are those that are unprocessed, i.e., salts that still have their complete natural profile of minerals.
- Note 2: Always use filtered water. The reason is that tap water tends to contain chlorine that can retard the fermentation process.
- Note 3: My food processor has a variable shredding blade that allows me to cut the cabbage into 2 mm shreds. I've found that 2 mm is the ideal size.
- Note 4: I use a canning funnel set on top of the mason jar to more easily add the cabbage to the mason jar.
- Note 5: I've used different weights through the years such as glass discs, 4 ounce mason jars, and ziploc bags filled with water. The glass discs and mason jars tend to work the best.