At Thanksgiving, friends and family members fight over getting a piece of Susan’s Perfect Pecan Pie. It’s dubbed perfect for two reasons: (1) It’s perfectly delicious; and (2) it took almost 10 years to perfect. After a lot of arm twisting, Susan relented and agreed to share her Perfect Pecan Pie recipe, and the story behind it, so I’m turning things over to Susan who writes . . .
At the Thanksgiving dinner table, there are always a few folks who don’t get exactly what they want. There aren’t enough drumsticks, the mashed potatoes are too lumpy, Susie didn’t make her Mac & Cheese, there are no lumps in the mashed potatoes, the deep-fried turkey is burnt, etc. All of that is trivial compared to the most important question of all – Pecan or Pumpkin – pie that is.
As a self-respecting Southern girl, I’ve got to go with Pecan! My recipe isn’t something that I got from the back of a bottle of Karo syrup, or a top-secret family recipe handed down through the generations.
It all began with a magnet purchased at the turn of the millennia on a birthday trip to New Orleans while I was living in Los Angeles.
The first time that I tried to make the pecan pie, it was a disaster. The problem was that I used refrigerated pie crusts that came in a roll, that I had to put in a glass Pyrex pie pan, as opposed to the frozen ones that come already in the pan. The crusts split, cracked ,and made a huge mess. You couldn’t cut the pie into slices, though I had no problem using a fork and eating just the filling. But over the years of tinkering with the original magnet recipe, and only having certain types of Karo syrup and brown sugar on hand, I have finally come up with the Perfect Pecan Pie.
Ingredients
My list of ingredients include frozen pie crusts, salted butter, light brown sugar, dark brown sugar, light Karo syrup, dark Karo sugar, vanilla extract, eggs, and toasted pecans.
Making the Perfect Pecan Pie
I start out by creaming the butter on medium speed for two minutes.
Then I add both brown sugars, and beat it on medium speed for two minutes. Next I add the Karo syrups and vanilla extract and beat for two minutes. Then I add the eggs, one at a time, while the mixer is running. For me, it’s easier to crack all of the eggs into a bowl, then add the eggs from the bowl. With the additions and beating, I do a fair amount of scraping down the sides and bottom of the bowl with a silicone spatula.
Unlike traditional recipes that have you adding the pecans to the batter, I sprinkle pecans in the uncooked pie shell, and then add the batter using a soup ladle. One thing about the pecans – it’s critical that you break the pecans into small pieces, and toast them before adding them to the pie shell. In fact, you should always toast pecans before adding them to any recipe!
My recipe for the Perfect Pecan Pie is enough to make two regular sized pies plus 16 mini pies, or two deep dish pies. Because I planned to send some mini pecan pies to a friend, I used a regular size pie shell. For the mini pecan pies, I added 1 tablespoon of pecans to the mini pie shell, and topped it with 2 tablespoons of the batter.
I baked the regular sized pies in a 450° F oven for 10 minutes, and then reduced the heat to 350° F and cooked them for another 35 minutes. I use the jiggle test to see if they’re done. That is, I jiggle the baking sheet that the pies are on to see how much they jiggle. If they jiggle too much, I bake the pies for another 5 minutes or so. I baked the minis at 325° F for 40 minutes. These pies freeze beautifully, and are actually better served cold.
I hope you enjoy them as much as my family and friends do!
Susan
If you’re looking for some more Pecan Pie goodness, check out these Pecan Pie Mini Muffins.
I hope you liked this recipe for Susan’s Perfect Pecan Pie as much as I do. If so, please consider rating it and leaving a comment. Also, if you’d like to receive notifications of new posts by email, ever your email address in the Subscribe box.
Thank you so much for visiting Pudge Factor. I hope you’ll come back!
Recipe
Susan’s Perfect Pecan Pie
Ingredients
- 2 frozen pie shells (See Note 1)
- ½ cup (1 stick) salted butter room temperature
- 1 cup light brown sugar packed
- 1 cup dark brown sugar packed
- 1 cup light Karo syrup
- 1 cup dark Karo syrup
- 1 Tablespoon vanilla extract
- 6 large eggs
- 4 cups pecan pieces toasted
Instructions
- Preheat oven to 450° F.
- Cream butter in large bowl on medium speed for 2 minutes. Add light brown sugar; beat on medium for 2 minutes. Scrape sides of bowl with silicone spatula.
- Add dark brown sugar; beat on medium for 2 minutes. Scrape sides of bowl with silicone spatula.
- Add light Karo syrup; beat on medium for 2 minutes. Scrape sides and bottom of bowl with silicone spatula.
- Add dark Karo syrup; beat on medium for 2 minutes. Scrape sides and bottom of bowl with silicone spatula.
- Add vanilla extract; beat on medium for 2 minutes. Scrape sides and bottom of bowl with silicone spatula.
- Add eggs, one at a time; beating until yolk disappears. Scrape sides and bottom of bowl with silicone spatula.
- Add 1-½ cups of pecan pieces to pie shell. Ladle batter over pecans until mixture reaches the line in the shell where the fluting starts. Repeat with remaining shell.
- Bake at 450° F for 10 minutes. Reduce heat to 350° F and continue baking for another 35 minutes.
- Remove from oven; cool completely on wire rack.
- *If using regular size pie shells, fill 16 mini pie shells with 1 tablespoon of chopped pecans and 2 tablespoons of batter. Bake at 325° F for 40 minutes. If using deep dish pie shells, fill shells with 2 cups of chopped pecans and divide batter between the two shells. Bake at 450° F for 10 minutes; reduce the heat to 350° F and continue baking for another 45 minutes. Cool completely.
- Note: Can be prepared in advance, and frozen. Best served cold.
Tips/Notes
- If using regular size pie shells, fill 16 mini pie shells with 1 tablespoon of chopped pecans and 2 tablespoons of batter. Bake at 325° F for 40 minutes. If using deep dish pie shells, fill shells with 2 cups of chopped pecans and divide batter between the two shells. Bake at 450° F for 10 minutes; reduce the heat to 350° F and continue baking for another 45 minutes. Cool completely.
- Can be prepared in advance, and frozen. Best served cold.
This pie is absolutely delicious! And, I love the story behind it.
When making the mini pies, did you guy these crust already prepared? I’ve seen the deep dish crusts but not refrigerated mini crusts……..
She used Dutch Ann Frozen Tart Shells purchased from Walmart. (https://www.walmart.com/ip/Dutch-Ann-Frozen-Tart-Shells-10-oz/10813455). Hope that helps!
They ARE Amazing Desserts!