Copycat Chocolate Chocolate Chip Bundtinis

Jump to Recipe Print Recipe

If you’ve been searching for a copycat recipe for Nothing Bundt Cake Chocolate Chocolate Chip Bundtinis, look no further! The cake and frosting have the same great look, taste and texture as the real thing.

I used the same Bundtini paper cups that are used by Nothing Bundt Cake. The tip that I used to frost the Bundtinis created the same swirled effect.

Now, you can make these delicious confections for a fraction of the cost of the real thing.

Estimated reading time: 9 minutes

Ingredients for Bundtinis
Special Equipment for Copycat Chocolate Chocolate Chip Bundtinis
How to Make these Adorable Bundtinis
Frequently Asked Questions

Ingredients for Bundtinis

Believe it or not, the starting point for these delicious little bundt cakes is a boxed cake mix. The actual ingredients are as follows:

Devils Food Boxed Cake Mix: I started with basic Duncan Hines 15.25 ounce boxed cake mix.
Chocolate Instant Pudding: Pudding enhances the moisture of the cake. You can purchase boxed cake mixes with pudding added. However, I like to add my own. That way, I know exactly how much goes into the cake.
Sour Cream: I used light sour cream. Sour cream adds moisture without thinning the cake batter. Because of its acidity, it also serves to activate the baking soda in the cake mix.
Mayonnaise: You might think that mayonnaise is totally out of place in a cake batter. However, if you think about it, mayonnaise is an emulsion made with eggs, oil and vinegar. With the mayonnaise, you can reduce the number of eggs that you would otherwise add to the batter. The oil makes the cake tender. The vinegar enhances the chocolate taste.
Eggs: It should come as no surprise that eggs are added to the cake batter!
Milk: Rather than adding water to the cake mix, I added milk to enhance the richness of the Bundtinis.
Vegetable Oil: Just like the eggs, vegetable oil is a standard addition to a boxed cake mix. You might be tempted to use butter instead for flavor. Actually, vegetable oil is better. Cakes made with oil tend to be more airy than cakes made with butter. Also, they stay moist and tender longer than cakes made with butter.
Chocolate Chips: The name is Chocolate Chocolate Chip, so this should come as no surprise! I used semi-sweet chocolate chips.

The ingredients for the frosting included cream cheese, heavy cream, salt and confectioners’ sugar.

Special Equipment for Copycat Chocolate Chocolate Chip Bundtinis

It’s one thing to copy the cake and frosting for the Copycat Chocolate Chocolate Chip Bundtinis and quite another to copy the appearance. For the appearance, several things were important:

Bundtini Pan: Bundtinis are mini bundt cakes. Therefore, the pan needed to be a mini Bundt Cake pan. There are a lot to choose from. To me, the shape and size were the most important characteristics. I settled on the NordicWare Bundt Brownie Pan. The shape was perfect. It produced cakes that were little bit larger than the Nothing Bundt Cake Bundtinis. However, they still fit into the paper cups.
Paper Cups: The Katgely Floret Brioche Paper Cups were the perfect match to the paper cups used by Nothing Bundt Cake for its Bundtinis. They were the exact size, shape and color!
Decorating Tip: I tried several different decorating tips for the frosting before I found the perfect one – Wilton #4B Open Star Tip. It produced the same detailed swirls in the frosting as the Nothing Bundt Cake Bundtinis. I actually got this tip from Michaels.
Piping Bag: I always use disposable piping bags, but any piping bag would work.

How to Make these Adorable Bundtinis

Time needed: 55 minutes

I made these amazing Chocolate Chocolate Chip Bundtinis as follows:

Adding the Dry and Wet Ingredients
I started by whisking together the cake mix and chocolate pudding in a large bowl.

Then, I added the sour cream, mayonnaise, eggs, milk and vegetable oil to the dry ingredients.
Combining the Dry and Wet Ingredients
I beat the ingredients together on low speed with my electric mixer just until they were combined. Then, I added the chocolate chips to the batter.
Combining the Chocolate Chips
Next, I used a silicone spatula to fold the chocolate chips into the bundtini batter.
Transferring Batter to Bundtini Pan
Even though the pan that I used for the Bundtinis was non-stick, I sprayed it well with a non-stick spray like Baker’s Joy. Then, I used a 1 ¾-inch ice cream scoop to fill the cups of the pan ⅔ of the way full.
Baking the Bundtinis
I popped the pan into a preheated 350°F oven for about 20 minutes. After 20 minutes, the tops of the Bundtinis sprung back when I lightly pressed on them and the sides had begun to pull away from the pan.

I removed the pan from the oven and let it cool on a wire rack for about 5 minutes. After 5 minutes, I removed the Bundtinis from the pan and let them cool completely on a wire rack.
Trimming the Buntinis
As the buntinis cooked, they spread a bit over the cup at the top. In order for them to fit inside of the brioche paper cups, I needed to trim the overhang.

To do this, I placed a buntini upside down. Using a small paring knife, I cut around the perimeter to remove the overhang. Then, I placed the buntini in the paper cup. It fit perfectly!

I repeated this with the remaining buntinis.
Preparing the Frosting
While the bundtinis were cooling, I made a cream cheese frosting. Typically, cream cheese frosting contains butter. However, the butter tends to give the frosting a yellowing tint. To minimize the yellowing tint, I used heavy cream in place of the butter. This worked like a charm!

I started by beating together the cream cheese, cream and salt until it was light and fluffy. Then, I gradually added the confectioners’ sugar, beating well after each addition.
Frosting the Bundtinis
As a final step, I frosted the bundtinis. I started by adding the frosting to a piping bag fitted with a #4B open star tip. Then, I swirled the frosting on top of each of the bundtinis.

I ended up with 24 amazing Copycat Chocolate Chocolate Bundtinis. They looked and tasted like the real thing at a fraction of the cost. Yum!

Frequently Asked Questions

Can you use either light sour cream or full-fat sour cream in this recipe?

I generally use light sour cream. However, full-fat sour cream would also work in this recipe.

I really don’t want to add mayonnaise to this recipe. Is there a substitute?

Mayonnaise may seam like an odd ingredient in this recipe. If you would prefer to omit the mayonnaise, you could increase the amount of sour cream by ¼ of a cup and add an additional egg.

What type of cream cheese do you use in the frosting recipe?

I tend to use full-fat cream cheese when I make the frosting. However, low-fat cream cheese also works well.

Where did you get the pan used to make these bundtinis?

I actually experimented with several pans before I found the perfect one – the NordicWare Bundt Brownie Pan. I ordered it from Amazon.com.

Where did you get the paper cups used for the bundtinis?

I used the Katgely Floret Brioche Paper Cups. They are an exact match to the cups used by Nothing Bundt Cake! I purchased them from Amazon.com.

How long will the bundtinis last?

You should store the bundtinis, covered in the refrigerator. When stored in the refrigerator, they should last up to five days.

If you’re interested in another awesome recipe that imitates the appearance Nothing Bundt Cake Bundtinis, you should try my Southern Hummingbird Mini-Bundtlettes!

I first published this blog on January 17, 2020. Since then, I’ve made these amazing treats a number of times. This update reflects updated pictures, updated text and updated procedures.

If you liked the recipe for Copycat Chocolate Chocolate Chip Bundtinis, please consider rating it and leaving a comment. I’d love to know how you liked it!

✯ Thank you so much for visiting Pudge Factor. I hope you’ll come back! ✯

Recipe